Kurban Said, Author Overlook Press $ (p) ISBN Nino, ensconced in a villa in Tehran, keeps her pregnancy by Ali a secret as. Quite the contrary, for Ali and Nino by Kurban Said is a thrilling love the Azerbaijani Muslim Ali and the Georgian Christian Nino in Baku in. Out of print for nearly three decades until the hardcover re-release last year, Ali and Nino is Kurban Said’s masterpiece. It is a captivating novel.

Author: Nahn Mizahn
Country: Qatar
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Medical
Published (Last): 9 February 2013
Pages: 98
PDF File Size: 7.79 Mb
ePub File Size: 8.21 Mb
ISBN: 769-5-40198-210-3
Downloads: 24914
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Vidal

Near the end of the novel, we see Ali in the act sald writing it. The neutrality of this section is disputed. Ali then flees to Daghestan to escape the vengeance of Nachararyan’s family. Ultimately the lovers are drawn back to Baku, but when war threatens their future, Ali is forced to choose between his loyalty to the beliefs of his Asian ancestors and his profound devotion to Nino. In an unsettled time riven by tensions between East and West, Muslim and Christian, there is one classic novel that can provide insight into our current situation even though it offers ssid solutions.

Ali And Nino

She links Chamanzaminli to Ali and Nino through textual parallels, relying on proposed textual parallels between Chamanzaminli’s life and writings and the novel’s content as “irrefutable evidence. Archived copy as title Webarchive template wayback links NPOV disputes from January All NPOV disputes Wikipedia articles with possible conflicts of interest from January Articles with multiple maintenance issues Interlanguage link template link number Articles with specifically marked weasel-worded phrases from September All articles with unsourced statements Articles with unsourced statements from September All articles with vague or ambiguous time Vague or ambiguous time from September All articles with specifically marked weasel-worded phrases NPOV disputes from March Articles with unsourced statements from March CS1 German-language sources de Commons category link is on Wikidata.

This page was last edited on 26 Decemberat Why doesn’t Nino leave him at this point? Why is it significant that he wishes to marry her in Moscow and then take her to Sweden? The romance between the Azerbaijani Muslim Ali and the Georgian Christian Nino in Baku in the wake of World War I obliges the partners to bridge the wide gulf between their two cultures even in a world where Muslims and Christians live peaceably side by side.

Baronin Elfriede Ehrenfels v. How would their lives have been different had they lived in Persia, for example, rather than Azerbeidshan?

Ali and Nino | Washington Independent Review of Books

Blair’s second hypothetical scenario involves a kufban in IstanbulTurkey rather than BerlinGermany or Vienna, Austria. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page.


Fikret Vezirov has proffered the claim that Chamanzaminli had to hide his identity behind the name Kurban Said so that he would not be identified with the anti-Bolshevik views contained in Ali and Nino. If Chamanzaminli had a copy of the manuscript, Vezirov said, it must have been among those Vezirov reports Chamanzaminli burning in kyrban citation needed ] when Chamanzaminli fell under the suspicion of the KGB.

Ali and Nino live in the cosmopolitan, oil-rich city of Baku, capital of Azerbaijan. Why is Ali swept up in the religious procession of flagellants and dervishes in Persia?

The sentence structure shows that he is not German. What larger trust has been betrayed by Nachararyan’s treachery? Tenderly I moved the cover down.

From the beginning, in and Baroness Ehrenfels held the legal copyright to the works of Kurban Said[30] a copyright that has now passed by inheritance to her niece Leela Ehrenfels. Chamanzaminli lived in Paris in the years to Of the way Ali abd him? Nino flees to Georgia with their child, while Ali Khan dies in battle as the Bolsheviks take the country.

My library Help Advanced Book Search. Do you think attitudes toward women in Islamic countries have changed much during the sixty years since the novel was published? Tal, the novel’s original publisher, believed that “Essad Bey” Nussimbaum had krban written it but that she was not sure as her husband Peter had dealt with the contracts but had died suddenly of a heart attack and she had fled Vienna with xnd Anshcluss.

Your subscription to Read More was successful.

From Georgia reported that “Vazirov the younger called Lev Nussimbaum a fraudster, a ‘charlatan’, not a Bakuvian, who wrote twelve books ‘of an adventurist nature’ but had nothing to do with Ali and Nino. Blair offers the two hypothetical scenarios, rather ninl a documentary paper trail, as a theory of sqid something conjecturally written by Chamanzaminli would have been published in an altered form as Ali and Nino in Blair asserts that Nussimbaum could not have acquired the knowledge of Azerbaijan evident in Ali and Nino alu his time in Bakuwhich ended when he was 14 years old, and during which time he had limited contact with Azerbaijani life.

Schoenberg on May 31, Az – Georgian director hopes to make documentary on Ali and Nino novel”. Considering the Berlin connection too remote, Blair proposes a Vienna connection. Tietze, perhaps the first to give credence to the Chamanzaminli theory, commented that “the evidence, although not conclusive, kutban have a certain weight, and perhaps Chamanzaminli is really identical with Kurban Said.

Solving the Mystery of a Strange and Dangerous NinpReiss makes a thorough case that the novel is the work of Nussimbaum, which continues a claim dating to Nussimbaum’s correspondence and writings — and the alli of Ahmed Giamil Vacca-Mazzara in the s. Omar Rolf von Ehrenfels was the husband of Baroness Elfriede Ehrenfels von Bodmershof and coincidentally the father of Kruban Ehrenfels, the current copyright holder. Much of this echoes Tom Reiss’s account of Nussimbaum’s writing.


Feature in Words For Thought More. Compare the two final scenes. Thus, while Reiss has not claimed absolute proof that Nussimbaum, rather than Ehrenfels or Chamanzaminli, is the primary author, he does cite documentary evidence showing that Nussimbaum had a need in to “Aryanize” his publications in order to continue to generate income from them, was receiving income from checks written to the name of Kurban Said, made several documented references identifying himself as Kurban Said, and continued to use the pseudonym on his final, unpublished manuscript Der Mann der Nichts von der Liebe Verstand.

In what ways does the above passage prefigure the novel’s main thematic developments? One is that the April 20, working title of the novel was The Dying Orientand her father and aunt the Baron and Baroness Ehrenfels had previously written an article together entitled “The Dying Istanbul.

Nussimbaum explains that Ali and Nino could still be published everywhere, since “according to the law on pseudonyms, K. He tried to show that he was related to Essad Kurba four generations back and, thus, Essad Bey’s only living descendent, and therefore in line to inherit Essad Bey’s royalties from his various books.

Ali and Nino · Kurban Said · Könyv · Moly

In retaliation, Ali pursues him on horseback, overtakes his “lacquered box” car and stabs him to death with a dagger. The characters, settings, and plot all combine to make this book come alive. Reiss counters Barazon’s point by arguing that Nussimbaum had an economic incentive to publish under a pseudonym owned by his friend the Baroness Ehrenfels because, as opposed to Austria and Switzerlandwhere Nussimbaum could have published under his pen name Essad BeyNazi -controlled Germany was the largest market by far for German-language publications.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. How is this decision first received? Injia analyzed kyrban two books, found similar and identical passages, and concluded that ” Kurban Said ” whom she identifies as Essad Bey deliberately transferred passages from Robakidze’s novel.